You can visit the same island on two different trips and come home with very different memories. On one, you follow a guide between sightseeing stops and meet other travellers. On the other, you spend an hour swimming beside your yacht, have lunch with your own friends and decide together what you would like to do next.
If you are choosing between a private yacht charter and a shared speedboat tour in Phuket, start with the day you want to have. A group tour can be a straightforward way to see famous places with a ready-made programme. A private yacht gives your party exclusive use of the boat and more scope to shape the experience.
There are two choices here: the type of boat and the booking format. Speedboats can also be chartered privately. In this guide, we compare a crewed private yacht or catamaran with a join-in speedboat excursion.
1. Who Shares the Boat With You
On a shared tour, you book places on a departure with other travellers. That can suit a couple or a solo traveller who enjoys meeting people and wants the arrangements taken care of. Group size varies: some operators specialise in small groups, so a shared trip does not automatically mean a crowded boat.
On a private charter, the guest spaces are reserved for your party, with the crew there to run the trip. This makes a difference when you want a family day, a celebration or time together without sharing the boat with people you have not met.
The islands themselves remain shared places. Booking a yacht does not give exclusive access to a beach or lagoon.

2. How the Route Is Chosen
A shared excursion is sold around a published itinerary. You choose the tour whose stops interest you, and its crew manages the programme for everyone aboard. The order of visits may still change with conditions.
A private charter starts with your group's priorities. You might prefer fewer stops, more swimming or a route focused on limestone scenery. We discuss those wishes alongside the yacht, departure marina and available time.
That flexibility has practical limits. Weather, tides, access rules, passage distances and the agreed return time all matter. A captain may need to alter a private itinerary too. Our guide to choosing between Chalong and Ao Po explains how the departure point affects the plan.

3. Speed and Time at Each Stop
A speedboat is worth considering when your priority is reaching a distant island within a day. A sailing catamaran generally travels more slowly, so a long outward and return passage can leave less time at the destination.
For Phi Phi in one day, we recommend considering a motor yacht or power catamaran for a private trip. A sailing catamaran is better planned with an overnight stay. This is why comparing boats only by the number of hours hired can be misleading.
On a shared excursion, time at each stop forms part of the group programme. A private charter gives more room to agree how that time is used: an extra swim may be worth more to your group than another stop. Changes still need to fit the day's plan.
4. Space to Spend the Day
Look at the layout as carefully as the exterior photographs. Where will everyone sit in the shade? Is there a table for lunch? What toilet and changing facilities are available? How do guests get in and out of the water?
A cruising yacht or catamaran may offer separate areas for eating, lounging and resting. Which areas are available to day guests should be confirmed for the particular boat. On a speedboat, seating and facilities vary by model; some have substantial shade and an onboard toilet.
Think about the members of your party who may spend more time aboard. Comfortable seating and an easy place to rest can matter as much as the list of islands. Boat size alone does not guarantee a comfortable ride in every sea condition.

5. Lunch and Personal Requests
Shared tour packages often include meals, drinks and snorkelling equipment. Lunch may be at an island restaurant or another planned venue. Check the package: a shared tour can include a well-organised meal and accommodate some dietary requests when arranged beforehand.
With a private yacht, we can discuss how food fits into your day, from lunch on board to a celebration cake or a special menu. Availability and additional costs depend on the chosen charter.
Tell us about allergies and dietary requirements before booking. Do not assume a particular menu, chef, alcoholic drink or restaurant stop is included simply because the boat is private. The written quotation should make the arrangements clear.

6. What Everyone Does at Anchor
Group tours can combine sightseeing, beach visits, swimming and snorkelling within one organised day. This works well when the published activities match what you want to do.
On a private yacht, your group can plan more time around a favourite activity. Some guests may want to swim while others stay aboard with a book. Depending on the boat and agreed package, options may include SUP, a floating pool or fishing equipment.
Water toys are specific to the yacht and booking, and their use depends on the conditions and crew's instructions. Kayaking excursions may involve a separate local service. Our guide to things to do on a yacht in Phuket helps you think through the kind of day your group will enjoy.

7. How to Compare the Total Cost
Join-in tours are usually priced per person. Private yacht charters are generally quoted for the boat and crew, with the final amount depending on the yacht, date, route, guest numbers and agreed services.
For a solo traveller or couple, buying seats on a group departure can be easier to fit into the budget. For a larger party, it is worth requesting a private quote and calculating the cost per guest. It will not automatically be cheaper: the yacht and the package still matter.
Compare the complete totals. Check transfers, meals, park or admission fees, equipment, taxes and optional extras in each offer. Our guide to what a private charter includes explains the questions to ask.
The Two Formats at a Glance
| What matters to you | Shared speedboat tour | Private yacht charter |
|---|---|---|
| Company on board | Other travellers join the departure | Your party and the crew |
| Planning | Choose a published programme | Agree the route around your wishes and practical limits |
| Pace | Timings work for the group | More scope to adjust time at stops |
| Space | Check the actual speedboat layout | Check the yacht's seating, shade and guest areas |
| Meals | Follow the tour package | Agree the menu and any extras |
| Activities | Follow the advertised programme | Plan around your interests and available equipment |
| Budget | Usually per person | Usually a boat quotation, with inclusions to confirm |
Which Trip Fits Your Holiday?
A shared speedboat tour is worth considering if its itinerary already matches your wish list, you enjoy meeting other travellers and you prefer to book individual places on an organised departure.
A private yacht is a good fit when spending time with your own group is central to the day. It also gives you more scope to plan a celebration, allow for different interests and spend time aboard between island stops.
Start with three details: who is coming, which experience matters most and how much of the day you want to spend travelling. Those answers make choosing the boat much easier.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can we book a private yacht just for two people?
Yes. You can charter a yacht for two, but the quotation is for the agreed private charter rather than two seats on a shared departure.
Does a private yacht mean we can visit any island?
No. The yacht's speed, departure point, charter length, sea conditions and access restrictions determine what is practical. Discuss any essential destination before confirming the boat.
Is a private yacht always the better choice for children?
It depends on the children, boat and route. Compare the crossing, boarding arrangements, shade, suitable life jackets and places to rest. Tell the operator the children's ages and any specific needs before booking.


